About | Portfolio | Backup | Archives | PayPal Tip Jar | Amazon Tip Jar | Shop@Amazon
Advertising


Search BillHobbs.com
Stats, Etc.


TTLB Ecosystem Stats
Powered by FeedBurner


« Full Moon | Main | Defending Hargett »

August 20, 2005

The Wrong Target

The Tennessean has raised the possibility in both story and an editorial that state Rep. Tre Hargett might have voted Pfizer's way on an important piece of legislation, while also seeking a job with Pfizer as a lobbyist. As I outlined here, there is no evidence of that - and the legislation, the Tennessee Affordable Drug Act of 2005, passed the state House on a vote of 93-0. Hargett was one of six legislators who did not vote.

Hargett, as the news media has reported, is member of three legislative committees through which the legislation - HB 1410 - passed. But no news media has reported on how Hargett voted on HB 1410 in those committees.

I am doing the digging they haven't done.

Hargett is a member of the Health & Human Resources Committee, the FInance, Ways and Means Committee, and the Calendar and Rules Committee.

According to House records, the legislation was approved by a voice vote in both H&HR on May 10 and FW&M on May 19.

The Calendar and Rules Committee then placed the bill on the calendar for the full House, which passed it 93-0 on May 24.

As the legislation passed by voice vote in committee, there is no official record of how Hargett voted. So I emailed the chairman and vice-chairman of both committees to ask their recollection of how Hargett voted on HB 1410, and whether he spoke in committee or privately against the bill.

So far, I have heard from Rep. Joe Armstrong, chairman of H&HR, who said, "I do not recall," and from Rep. Craig Fitzhugh, chairman FW&M, who emailed this response: "My memory is not the best and the record will speak for itself, but I have no recollection of Rep. Hargett's vote on the matter. Neither do I recall whether he and I spoke about this bill."

I also emailed the prime sponsor of HB 1410, state Rep. David Shepard, D-Dickson. I have not heard back from him.

By the way, Rep. Shepard is a pharmacist. He had a clear conflict of interest in pushing the HB 1401, the Tennessee Affordable Drug Act of 2005.

So The Tennessean raises the possibility - sans evidence - that Hargett voted Pfizer's way on a piece of legislation that we know was sponsored and ushered through the legislture by a pharmacist who we know voted the pharmacy industry's way.

Okay, whatever.

Posted in Tennessee News | Linked By |
Please support HobbsOnline by doing your online shopping at Amazon.com
Comments

Hey Bill,
I think you're about to figure it out. Rep. Hargett can't remember how much "interviewing" he did with Pfizer during the last session, Committee members can't remember how they voted, the entire Republican membership of the Legislature were "entertained" by Pfizer, and the bill was approved. Evidence?? The State Legislature is exempt from the Sunshine Laws.
Tennesseans do not need anyone to point a finger of blame at one side or the other, as the Guilt belongs to the elected, the appointed and the lazy press. Blame is a waste of time or tomorrow's partisan spin.
Hargett gets a very cushy job and he knows all the secrets of the legislature. The puppet is now Puppeteer.
We residents all understand this, Bill. This is the normal state of the State.
We residents have had about all the Evidence we can stand.

Posted by: Joe P. at August 20, 2005 04:03 PM

Joe - the Tennessee Affordable Drug Act of 2005 was BAD for Pfizer. And it passed 93-0.

It was GOOD for the pharmacists of Tennessee. A pharmacist sponsored the bill and pushed it to passage.

Posted by: Bill Hobbs at August 20, 2005 06:02 PM

Great work, Bill.

David Shepard is famous for pushing bills that would benefit his practice.

If Tre' wanted to register a vote against the bill, even if it was a voice vote, he could have gone to the clerk and been recorded as a "No." Obviously, he didn't, so by practical effect, he voted against the people he was supposedly courting for a job. Very unethical, huh?

Posted by: Matthew White at August 20, 2005 09:52 PM

You are almost there again, Bill!
You are right - the act did pass, but it was the only one of over a dozen bills addressing the high cost of prescription drugs in TN --
The "Affordable Drug Act" was but one item in the 60-some-odd pages of recommendations from the Comptroller's Report on Medication policies in Tennessee. Most every bill died quietly in committee votes, the ones no one remembers -- bills like getting TN to join with other states to negotiate for lower prices, or the reducing costs in the gold-plated drug plans for state employees, or discounts for the elderly in the state (cited in particular for the high cost to state government) or how about providing annual oversight of the effectiveness of TN's drug policies, and the doctor-supported policy to engage in Disease Management rather than the constant Crisis Intervention techniques used today??? None of these passed out of committees. And how about requiring pharmaceutical companies to report how much they spend on legislative entertaining??
Oh and of course NO laws to stop the revolving door from the Legislative to the Lobbying branch of government, which is why Rep. Hargett's actions are so questionable.
Pfizer may have lost one battle on the Hill, but the state's residents lost all the other ones.

Posted by: Joe P. at August 20, 2005 11:40 PM
Post a comment
Comments Policy: Your comment is subject to deletion if it is off-topic or includes foul language or personal attack. Readers, please email me if you find comments that include egregious violations of this policy. Comments may not post immediately - do not post twice!









Remember personal info?






Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):




back to top
Lamar!

Find the Good
and Praise It
I Also Blog At...
button-fcs-blog.gif
Advertising

Archives
Blogroll