About | Portfolio | Backup | Archives | PayPal Tip Jar | Amazon Tip Jar | Shop@Amazon
Advertising


Search BillHobbs.com
Stats, Etc.


TTLB Ecosystem Stats
Powered by FeedBurner


« State Income Tax Ban Stalls | Main | Dictator Update: HB 0887 Dead »

May 4, 2005

Dictator UPDATE: WSMV's Bias is Showing

All of the facts are available to any journalist wanting to report the truth of what happened last week in the Tennessee legislature when House Speaker Jimmy Naifeh broke House rules in order to kill HB 0887, a gun-rights bill he opposes. The video of the April 27 and April 28 sessions are online, as are numerous facts about the case brought out by several enterprising bloggers and other citizens seeking the truth.

So, then, WSMV's story last night on the controversy was in every way it could be a complete failure to commit responsible, honest journalism. Blake Wylie has more, including a link to the WSMV story. (And it's a good thing Wylie caught it because I rarely watch WSMV anymore. They used to be good at journalism, but not anymore.)

For my past related entries, see the end of this post

Everyone at WSMV involved in producing their story last night should be ashamed. They produced an inaccurate, false and biased report. The truth is out there, thanks to blogs - but no thanks to WSMV.

WSMV's Alan Frio stated: "Speaker Naifeh squashed the bill when it got out of the Constitutional Protections subcommittee on procedural issues - in other words, Republicans didn't follow House rules."

Frio, it seems, has better command of his hair than of his facts.

Fact 1: The only people claiming House rules were broken in the subcomittee are opponents of the bill.

Fact 2: Video exists of Naifeh breaking House rules to force the bill back to the subcomittee.

You might want to email Frio and ask him to issue a correction. Ask him to be an honest reporter like Chris Bundgaard at WKRN who, when shown that he had made a mistake in his report on this story, quickly acknowledged it and corrected it. Send him the link to this post:
http://billhobbs.com/hobbsonline/006079.html

Tell Alan that truth is out there. Tell him all of the relevant video, plus statements from witnesses and from some of the people involved, are available on this blog or via this blog's links to other blogs. If Alan Frio and WSMV can't be bothered to prepare a thorough report, they should at least help their viewers find it by posting links to the blogosphere's coverage on their website.

Previous Posts:
Dictator Update: AP Moves Worthless Story - April 29
Dictator - April 27
Dictator Update: Naifeh Blinked! - April 28
Dictator Update: WKRN Story - April 28
Dictator Update: More Press Coverage - April 29
Dictator Update: Is Naifeh Like Saddam? - April 29
Dictator Update: What Really Happened in the Subcommittee - April 29
Dictator Update: Watch Naifeh Blink - April 29
Dictator Update: WKRN's Bundgaard Responds - April 29

Posted in Tennessee News | Linked By |
Please support HobbsOnline by doing your online shopping at Amazon.com
Comments

WSMV's report on their morning show today was so bad as to be bizarre. The story was "a controversial gun bill will be voted on today in sub-committee." As if the story was about a gun bill. As if gun bills weren't voted on (and killed) in subcommittees on a regular basis. The story of HB887 is Mr. Naifeh's attempt at obstructing the procedural process of the House. If you don't report THAT there is no story.

Bill, I disagree that WSMV is simply being bias--I'd contend at this point they are being partisan.

Posted by: sbk at May 4, 2005 03:40 PM

I emailed Frio re: the story basically with the complaint that Naifeh attacked the bill in order to distract the media regarding his actions on the floor--and it worked! I received this response from Mr. Frio:

Theresa:
The report you referred to, in my opinion, was fair and balanced.
I talked to the speaker of the house (opposed) and also spoke to
Curry Todd (sponsor of the legislation).
The legislation, is the story. Its about amending legislation that makes
it
Illegal to carry a permitted gun into areas that serve alcohol.
That's the controversy.
If you are referring to the move that the speaker made to kill the
legislation, I talked about that as well, but didn't dwell on it, we
have time constraints in broadcasting. But the real story is the
legislation.
I received a number of e mails from both sides of the issue, yours was
the only
Complaint.
Thank you for your comments,

Alan Frio

Posted by: Theresa at May 5, 2005 06:52 AM
Post a comment
Comments Policy: Your comment is subject to deletion if it is off-topic or includes foul language or personal attack. Readers, please email me if you find comments that include egregious violations of this policy. Comments may not post immediately - do not post twice!









Remember personal info?






Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):




back to top
Advertising

Video
Palin Acceptance Speech

McCain Acceptance Speech

I Also Blog At...
button-fcs-blog.gif
Archives
Blogroll