About | Portfolio | Backup | Archives | PayPal Tip Jar | Amazon Tip Jar | Shop@Amazon
Advertising


Search BillHobbs.com
Stats, Etc.


TTLB Ecosystem Stats
Powered by FeedBurner


« Bredesen Watch | Main | Loss »

January 24, 2005

Will Bredesen Turn TennCare Lemon Into Political Lemonade?

Two months ago, I predicted that Tennessee Gov. Phil Bredesen's budding plans to slash TennCare, Tennessee's goldplated Cadillac of a healthcare welfare program, were part of a grander political strategy that would result in Bredesen being portrayed not as the governor who gutted healthcare for the poor, but the governor who saved it, though perhaps under a different name. I wrote:

Bredesen is not just a former healthcare executive who knows how to make the numbers work in a very tricky industry. He's also a Democrat who believes in government healthcare for those who need but can't afford it. He's also a politician who wants to get re-elected governor and almost certainly has his eye on higher office - the U.S. Senate or higher. He doesn't want 400,000 citizens angered that he cut off their health coverage. He most certainly doesn't want an opponent in 2006 running ads featuring all sorts of low-income and medically uninsurable people "who lost their healthcare because of Gov. Bredesen."
My prediction appears to be coming true in a general sense. NashvillePost.com (subscription only) is reporting:
Bredesen creates 'health care safety net' task force
Gov. Phil Bredesen on Monday announced the creation of a new task force that will revisit the state’s health care safety net. Two weeks ago, Bredesen announced plans to remove over 320,000 adults from the TennCare population. At that time, Bredesen indicated that the state would need to revisit its safety net provisions, portions of which Bredesen said in a statement Monday "have atrophied in the shadow of a public health plan that has paid for everything, without limits."

Saying it was time to begin "re-working those safety net muscles" in order to provide some level of basic care to those who need it, Bredesen Monday called on providers "to do more." He added that strengthening the safety net meant "asking enrollees to make better use of community and faith-based clinics." He also called on state government to make "limited investments to help beef up some non-commercial health care outlets, including our county health departments."

Bredesen's press release is here. The executive order creating the task force is here. Audio from the press conference is here.

Posted in Bredesen Watch | Linked By |
Please support HobbsOnline by doing your online shopping at Amazon.com
Comments

Sorry, but I think all that this means is that Bredesen is not serious about a once-and-for-all solution for TennCare. Trim some here, open a new program there, twiddle with the numbers, and out pops a "reform" that just puts off the financial crisis for a few years.

Not that I expected anything else. His stance in late 2004 ("Looks like I'll have to kill TennCare") was obviously a negotiating ploy to get the Tennessee Justice people off of his backs. I personally don't believe he ever really intended to revert to Medicaid.

Is there an example in the history of the United States (heck, the *world*), in which a failed governmental program was "reformed" without changing its basic philosophy, and then worked long term? I can't think of one. The closest one could argue would be welform reform in the nineties, and there the basic philosophy *was* changed from "you can be on it as long as you want" to "it temporary - get over it".

For TennCare reform to conceivably work, it would have to undergo the same kind of philosophical change. As long as Bredesen or whoever is committed to the idea that healthcare is effectively an entitlement, there will be no long term stability in the program. It will grow and grow in cost, as all entitlements do. Those who job the system will benefit, and those who take care of themselves will bear the burden.

The problem is that Tennessee can't just print money or raise taxes to the levels that the federal government can. So the outcome is likely to be much worse than programs like Medicare at the federal level. I'm very afraid that we will follow California as the case study for how to screw up a state's economy with over-reaching government.

Posted by: Billy Hollis at January 24, 2005 08:07 PM

Seems there's race amongst the "I saw Bredesen first" writers :) Who done it???????????

Posted by: janie at January 24, 2005 08:46 PM

I've been writing about Bredesen - good stuff and bad - for quite awhile now.

Posted by: Bill at January 24, 2005 10:02 PM

I guess we need to get ready for another income tax protest because if TennCare survives in its current form, somebody will have to foot the bill.

Posted by: Glen Dean at January 25, 2005 11:17 PM

I guess we need to get ready for another income tax protest because if TennCare survives in its current form, somebody will have to foot the bill.

Posted by: Glen Dean at January 25, 2005 11:17 PM

Can Medical Banking Connect the Healthcare IT Dots for Politicians?

Among the prominent rising stars for the 2008 presidency are Senator Bill Frist (R-TN), Senator Hillary Clinton (D-NY) and former speaker of the house Newt Gingrinch. Have you noted that the most prominent common thread among them is healthcare technology?

Posted by: Ed Dodds at January 26, 2005 09:43 PM

I have some friends that tell me that Senators FRist and Alexander were promoters of and benefactors from TennCare. I am not a believer but not being native to Tennessee, I need some help researching this. Help.

Wade

Posted by: Wade Sims at April 6, 2005 01:03 PM

TO GOV.BREDESEN & ALL OTHERS INVOLVED:

Six yrs. ago I was living in my car. I
was alone & on the vergeof a breakdown,which did eventually happen. I was from a prominent family in Memphis,TN. My father was Nickolaus John Giardino, owner of his personal meat co. He took care of all you bigshots, but never boasted. He dressed appropriately & not to impress ANYONE! Because of Tenncare I am in therapy & I have been on the proper medication for my illness. I am a 51 yr. old woman & because of proper treatment & medication I am able to function today.Four yrs. ago I started back to school & will receive my Associate Degree this year. I do not expect Tenncare to be a lifelong answer,but my medication is a lifelong answer. Why can't Tenncare help me until I find a job with benefits, since I am alone & I have NOONE to help me since my father has passed away? You people will get your money back from me because until this happened I had worked since 1978.
I AM NOT A BUM! Why won't you help me now continue to help myself so in the end I will be helping others as an employee of the criminal justice system in TENNESSEE? I know most of you really don't care but I, a registered voter, do & so do many others.

Posted by: Maria G. Walker at May 28, 2005 02:49 PM
Post a comment
Comments Policy: Your comment is subject to deletion if it is off-topic or includes foul language or personal attack. Readers, please email me if you find comments that include egregious violations of this policy. Comments may not post immediately - do not post twice!









Remember personal info?






Email this entry to:


Your email address:


Message (optional):




back to top
Advertising

Video
Palin Acceptance Speech

McCain Acceptance Speech

I Also Blog At...
button-fcs-blog.gif
Archives
Blogroll